Your cart

Your cart is empty

See what's trending:

Who doesn't love a surprise?! Add a Mystery Item to your order!



Not everyone will get the same item and every month we will swap out the items so you don't have to worry about repeats. *Ordering multiple quantities will most likely result in receiving duplicate mystery items* You may receive a regular pair of plugs or something totally special and only available as a Mystery Item. So if you're ready to roll the dice, add your size to the cart. If your size is sold out, check back next month.

*We will not accept any special requests on what to send or not send*

*No refunds or returns on mystery items*

Mystery Item *February*

Regular price $ 5.00
Unit price
per 
3.9 (90)

Have questions? Contact us

Free domestic shipping on orders over $55

Start a wishlist

Sign up for rewards

Secure payment

Who doesn't love a surprise?! Add a Mystery Item to your order!



Not everyone will get the same item and every month we will swap out the items so you don't have to worry about repeats. *Ordering multiple quantities will most likely result in receiving duplicate mystery items* You may receive a regular pair of plugs or something totally special and only available as a Mystery Item. So if you're ready to roll the dice, add your size to the cart. If your size is sold out, check back next month.

*We will not accept any special requests on what to send or not send*

*No refunds or returns on mystery items*

Customer Reviews

Based on 90 reviews
63%
(57)
8%
(7)
4%
(4)
9%
(8)
16%
(14)
J
Jonathan

The gauges I got were for a woman, I am a man so I will never be wearing them. I really like the idea of a mystery set but maybe a “for a girl” “for a guy” option would be a good idea.

D
Dennis H.
Awesome Quality but needing more Variety.

My wife had gotten some mystery plugs a couple of weeks before I ordered these. I wanted to surprise her by getting her some more mystery plugs because she loved them so much. I am disappointed though, only because the same pair was sent. I was going to send them back but unfortunately I saw that you couldn’t return mystery items.

C
C.
Very pleased

Mystery bags/boxes are my weakness but they come with a certain risk of disappointment; they're sometimes a way for a company to offload unwanted stock. This is my first mystery item from AB but I'm very pleased with it! The plugs are nice quality and a style and color I'll wear a ton. I would easily have paid full price for these, so it's an amazing deal.

G
Gabrielle

I really like the blue-ish green color of the glass plugs can’t wait to put them on soon

C
Candice

I wouldn’t have chose the ones I received but actually really love them! I got a clear and teal set of glass plugs