Shop the Black Friday sale now!

We'll be back on Monday to ship orders and respond to messages.

Your cart

Your cart is empty

See what's trending:

Best Sellers

Plugs

Arctic Buffalo offers a huge variety of plugs in materials including silicone, glass, stone, stainless steel, brass, wood and more.
Browse our stock to find your next favorite pair of plugs! 
Need some guidance on stretching tips, methods, sizing, and cleaning? Go to our ear stretching guide. 

148 Results

Clear filters
Orange Single Flare Glass Plugs

Orange Single Flare Glass Plugs

5.0 (5)

from $ 23.50

Green Double Flare Glass Plugs *Discontinued* - 6mm
Sale

Green Double Flare Glass Plugs *Discontinued* - 6mm

5.0 (6)

$ 23.50 $ 8.25 65% off

Pawprint Glass Plugs *Discontinued*
Sale

Pawprint Glass Plugs *Discontinued*

4.9 (17)

from $ 9.50 61% off

Nautilus Shell Steel Plugs with Abalone *Discontinued*
Sale

Nautilus Shell Steel Plugs with Abalone *Discontinued*

3.9 (7)

from $ 13.40 Up to 39% off

Black Glass Cat Eye Single Flare Plugs

Black Glass Cat Eye Single Flare Plugs

4.5 (11)

from $ 17.75

Purple Heart Wood Double Flare Plugs

Purple Heart Wood Double Flare Plugs

3.5 (10)

from $ 23.00

Yellow Acrylic Rose Stainless Steel Single Flare Plugs

Yellow Acrylic Rose Stainless Steel Single Flare Plugs

4.5 (12)

from $ 20.00

Honeycomb Glass Plugs

Honeycomb Glass Plugs

4.6 (11)

from $ 24.00

Metallic Purple Glass Plugs

Metallic Purple Glass Plugs

4.7 (9)

from $ 24.00

Black Walnut Wood Double Flare Plugs

Black Walnut Wood Double Flare Plugs

2.6 (5)

from $ 23.00

Nautilus Shell Steel Plugs with Pearl Tentacles

Nautilus Shell Steel Plugs with Pearl Tentacles

5.0 (4)

from $ 21.00

Cobra Jasper Double Flare Plugs

Cobra Jasper Double Flare Plugs

4.4 (7)

from $ 17.75

Flesh Silicone Double Flare Plugs F1

Flesh Silicone Double Flare Plugs F1

4.4 (5)

from $ 16.00

African Padauk Wood Double Flare Plugs

African Padauk Wood Double Flare Plugs

4.0 (9)

from $ 23.00

Flesh Silicone Double Flare Plugs F2

Flesh Silicone Double Flare Plugs F2

3.7 (6)

from $ 16.00

Sodalite Concave Plugs

Sodalite Concave Plugs

4.5 (16)

from $ 28.25

Kiwi Jasper Plugs

Kiwi Jasper Plugs

5.0 (3)

from $ 17.75

Dark Blue Glass Cat Eye Single Flare Plugs

Dark Blue Glass Cat Eye Single Flare Plugs

4.8 (10)

from $ 17.75

Metallic Green Double Flare Glass Plugs

Metallic Green Double Flare Glass Plugs

5.0 (8)

from $ 24.50

Matte Red Silicone Plugs

Matte Red Silicone Plugs

4.9 (10)

from $ 16.00

Blue Double Flare Glass Plugs

Blue Double Flare Glass Plugs

4.6 (7)

from $ 23.00

Aqua Single Flare Glass Plugs

Aqua Single Flare Glass Plugs

4.6 (5)

from $ 23.50

Amazonite Single Flare Plugs

Amazonite Single Flare Plugs

4.3 (11)

from $ 19.25

Flesh Silicone Double Flare Plugs F3

Flesh Silicone Double Flare Plugs F3

3.3 (6)

from $ 16.00

No Flare Steel Plugs

No Flare Steel Plugs

3.7 (3)

from $ 18.50

Blue with Black Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

Blue with Black Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

4.7 (7)

from $ 24.00

Green Single Flare Glass Plugs *Discontinued*
Sale

Green Single Flare Glass Plugs *Discontinued*

4.6 (5)

from $ 12.50 Up to 48% off

Yellow Glass Cat Eye Single Flare Plugs

Yellow Glass Cat Eye Single Flare Plugs

4.5 (2)

from $ 17.25

Moss Agate Concave Plugs *Discontinued*
Sale

Moss Agate Concave Plugs *Discontinued*

5.0 (13)

from $ 16.24 Up to 33% off

Matte Dark Green Silicone Plugs

Matte Dark Green Silicone Plugs

4.9 (11)

from $ 16.00

Cider Orange Glass Plugs

Cider Orange Glass Plugs

4.6 (8)

from $ 23.00

Yellow Jade Double Flare Plugs

Yellow Jade Double Flare Plugs

3.6 (7)

from $ 16.75

Red Acrylic Rose Stainless Steel Single Flare Plugs

Red Acrylic Rose Stainless Steel Single Flare Plugs

4.8 (8)

from $ 20.00

Snakewood Single Flare Plugs

Snakewood Single Flare Plugs

5.0 (2)

from $ 23.00

Acrylic Resin Blood Plugs

Acrylic Resin Blood Plugs

5.0 (12)

from $ 20.00

Yellow Glass Cat Eye Plugs

Yellow Glass Cat Eye Plugs

4.1 (9)

from $ 18.25

Matrix Jasper Single Flare Plugs

Matrix Jasper Single Flare Plugs

4.0 (8)

from $ 16.25

Green with White Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

Green with White Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

5.0 (4)

from $ 24.00

Depth Gauge Matte Black Silicone Plugs

Depth Gauge Matte Black Silicone Plugs

5.0 (8)

from $ 16.00

Bloodwood Single Flare Plugs

Bloodwood Single Flare Plugs

4.0 (5)

from $ 23.00

Green with Black Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

Green with Black Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

5.0 (4)

from $ 24.00

Orange with White Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

Orange with White Swirl Single Flare Glass Plugs

4.6 (7)

from $ 24.00

Matte Purple Silicone Plugs

Matte Purple Silicone Plugs

4.2 (10)

from $ 16.00

Blue Single Flare Glass Plugs

Blue Single Flare Glass Plugs

4.9 (8)

from $ 24.00

Unakite Double Flare Plugs

Unakite Double Flare Plugs

4.7 (6)

from $ 16.75

Myanmar Maidu Wood Double Flare Plugs

Myanmar Maidu Wood Double Flare Plugs

5.0 (1)

from $ 23.00

Purple Heart Wood Single Flare Plugs

Purple Heart Wood Single Flare Plugs

4.0 (4)

from $ 23.00

Tree of Life Stainless Steel Teardrop Plugs with Mother of Pearl

Tree of Life Stainless Steel Teardrop Plugs with Mother of Pearl

4.8 (5)

from $ 25.00

White Jade Double Flare Plugs

White Jade Double Flare Plugs

5.0 (5)

from $ 17.50

Red/Black/White Marble Swirl Double Flare Glass Plugs

Red/Black/White Marble Swirl Double Flare Glass Plugs

5.0 (3)

from $ 24.00

Load more